Marc Darrow, MD, JD
A caller to my Living Pain-Free radio program described two problems: a herniated disc and a strained sacroiliac joint. The question was whether regenerative treatment could help. Before discussing an injection, however, we need to understand which structure is producing the pain.
This is a common problem in evaluating low back pain. Someone may have a disc bulge on an MRI and pain near the back of the pelvis, but those two findings do not automatically establish the same diagnosis. The disc, sacroiliac joint, surrounding ligaments, hip, or more than one structure may be involved.
SI-joint pain and disc-related pain can overlap. Pain location and movements that aggravate symptoms provide clues, but neither a symptom checklist nor an MRI alone can reliably identify the painful structure.
What is the sacroiliac joint, and why can it hurt?
The sacroiliac, or SI, joints connect the sacrum at the base of the spine to the pelvic bones. They help transfer the weight and forces of the upper body into the legs. Strong ligaments support this connection.
When people say “SI-joint pain,” they may mean pain arising inside the joint, pain from the supporting tissues behind it, or pain felt in that area but originating elsewhere. These distinctions matter because an injection into the joint does not treat every structure around it.
The terms also need clarification. Sacroiliitis means inflammation of the SI joint. SI-joint dysfunction is a broader clinical label often used for mechanical problems involving this region. Inflammatory arthritis, joint degeneration, ligament injury, and referred lumbar pain should not be treated as interchangeable conditions.
SI-joint pain versus disc pain: how do the symptoms compare?
| Clinical clue | Possible SI-joint or surrounding ligament pain | Possible disc-related pain or nerve irritation |
|---|---|---|
| Where it hurts | Often one side of the buttock or posterior pelvis, generally below the belt line; pain can extend toward the groin or thigh. | May involve the central low back or buttock. Irritation of a nerve root can produce radiating leg pain. |
| Activities that may aggravate it | Stairs, getting out of a car, rolling in bed, prolonged standing, or loading one leg. | Sitting and bending may aggravate some disc-related pain. Patterns vary considerably. |
| Numbness or weakness | Progressive weakness, altered reflexes, or a clear nerve distribution requires evaluation for another or additional cause. | Numbness, tingling, weakness, or reflex changes may occur when a nerve root is affected. |
| What helps establish the source | History, examination of the spine and hips, pain-provocation tests, and sometimes an image-guided diagnostic injection. | History, neurologic examination, symptom distribution, and imaging when indicated. |
These are patterns to discuss with a physician, not rules for diagnosing yourself. Disc pain is not synonymous with sciatica: a disc can be painful without compressing a nerve. Similarly, pain traveling into the leg does not automatically prove a herniated disc.
It might not be your SI joint
A study examining structural causes of pain referred to the SI region illustrates why we must look beyond the location a patient points to. Lumbar spinal disorders can produce pain in an area that seems to identify the SI joint. The location is useful information, but it is only the beginning of the evaluation. (1)
Other possible sources include lumbar facet joints, spinal or pelvic ligaments, gluteal tendons, muscle attachments, hip arthritis, and hip labral problems. We also need to consider whether more than one source is contributing.
For example, a patient may have an abnormal lumbar MRI and painful loading around the pelvis. The examination needs to determine whether the imaging explains the familiar pain, whether there is a separate pelvic problem, or whether both are relevant. For more on overlapping hip symptoms, see Is your pain really coming from the hip joint?
Why a herniated disc on MRI may not explain your pain
MRI is an important tool, but an abnormal finding is not the same as a proven pain generator. A systematic review of 3,110 people without symptoms found spinal degeneration and disc bulges to be common, with prevalence increasing with age. (2)
This does not mean the MRI should be ignored. Imaging can help identify nerve compression, stenosis, fracture, infection, and other significant structural disease. The question is whether the finding fits the history, examination, and neurologic signs.
When I evaluate a person with back pain, I want to understand what hurts during daily activities, which movements reproduce it, and whether the area of tenderness matches the suspected diagnosis. A scan cannot replace those questions. Equally, tenderness alone cannot prove that a disc or nerve problem is irrelevant.
How SI-joint pain is evaluated
The examination should include the lumbar spine, hips, gait, strength, and neurologic function. Clinicians may use several SI-joint pain-provocation maneuvers together. No single maneuver confirms the diagnosis, and positive tests do not establish which treatment will succeed.
An image-guided local anesthetic injection can sometimes help assess pain from inside the SI joint. Its interpretation depends on the technique, the amount of relief, and whether the patient’s usual painful activities improve. It also has false-positive and false-negative limitations. Importantly, a joint-space block does not fully evaluate pain in the posterior ligaments. Multispecialty guidelines distinguish intra-articular and extra-articular SI-joint complex pain. (3)
What about pain after fusion, hip replacement, or pelvic injury?
A history of lumbar fusion, hip replacement, or pelvic trauma deserves attention during the evaluation. These events may change loading or introduce additional potential pain sources. They do not prove that the SI joint is responsible. Persistent pain after surgery also requires consideration of the original spinal condition and possible surgical complications.
Inflammatory bowel disease or a history suggesting inflammatory spinal arthritis should prompt a different diagnostic discussion. Local injections do not replace appropriate assessment and management of an underlying inflammatory disorder.
Can ligaments contribute even when the MRI shows disc degeneration?
Ligaments help guide and restrain spinal and pelvic movement. Their contribution can be overlooked when the discussion focuses entirely on discs.
Biomechanical modeling by Ellingson and colleagues examined disc degeneration and ligament failure separately. The work supports a distinction between changes related to disc degeneration and changes related to compromised ligament support. It was a mechanical study, not a clinical trial proving that injections repair ligaments or relieve back pain. (4)
My clinical emphasis is to examine the supporting tissues as well as the spine. A patient can have an imaging diagnosis and a separate painful soft-tissue problem. That possibility deserves investigation without assuming that every patient has instability or that every tender ligament needs an injection.
What treatments are considered before PRP or bone marrow concentrate?
Treatment depends on the diagnosis. Options may include progressive exercise, physical therapy, activity modification, hip and trunk strengthening, and medication when appropriate. Some patients find an SI belt helpful for temporary support.
Corticosteroid injections aim to reduce inflammation. Radiofrequency procedures target selected pain-transmitting nerves. SI-joint fusion is considered in selected patients with persistent, confirmed SI-joint pain after appropriate nonsurgical care. These approaches serve different purposes.
A failed steroid injection does not automatically establish ligament injury. Temporary anesthetic relief does not guarantee a successful fusion. Before moving to another procedure, we should reconsider whether the working diagnosis and treatment target remain convincing.
PRP for SI-joint pain: what does the research show?
Platelet-rich plasma, or PRP, is prepared from a patient’s blood and contains concentrated platelets and signaling proteins. It is being investigated for selected musculoskeletal pain conditions. SI-joint studies have produced mixed results.
A randomized trial favored corticosteroids
A double-blind randomized trial published in 2022 included 26 patients with substantial temporary relief after a diagnostic SI-joint block. Both PRP and corticosteroid groups improved, but steroid recipients had lower pain scores and more responders at the earlier follow-ups. This study does not support a general claim that PRP works better than steroids for SI-joint pain. (5)
A 2026 retrospective study favored PRP at six months
A 2026 study compared PRP, corticosteroid, and hyaluronic-acid injections in 60 adults with sacroiliitis, with 20 people in each group. Steroids provided faster early relief, while the PRP group had better pain and disability scores at six months. Because treatment was not randomly assigned and the study was small, it provides preliminary comparative evidence. (6)
A September 2026 randomized trial adds useful caution
A CT-guided randomized trial enrolled 44 people with block-confirmed SI-joint pain; 40 remained for analysis at three months. Both treatment groups improved. PRP showed encouraging trends, but the between-group difference in the primary pain outcome was not statistically significant. The responder-rate difference was also not statistically significant. Larger studies with longer follow-up are needed before claiming superior durability. (7)
For patients, the practical interpretation is that PRP may be discussed as an option in selected circumstances, but superiority over corticosteroids is not established. Differences in PRP preparation, diagnostic selection, injection location, and follow-up make studies difficult to compare.
What is bone marrow concentrate?
Bone marrow aspirate concentrate—BMAC or BMC—is prepared from a patient’s own bone marrow. It is a mixture of cells and signaling substances, including a small population of stromal and progenitor cells. It is not a purified stem-cell product.
“Stem cell therapy” is a familiar term, but it can give the impression that an injection predictably turns into a new disc or ligament. That has not been established. The research discussed here concerns non-expanded autologous bone marrow concentrate; findings from laboratory-expanded cell products should not be transferred to these procedures.
Bone marrow concentrate for disc pain: early studies and the sham-controlled trial
A retrospective study of 33 patients receiving intradiscal concentrated bone marrow aspirate reported improvements in some patients with suspected discogenic pain. Without a control group, and with incomplete follow-up, the study could not establish how much benefit came from the treatment itself. (8)
A stronger 2025 double-blind randomized study compared a single intradiscal BMC injection with a sham procedure in 63 patients. It found no statistically significant differences in the principal pain or disability outcomes at three, six, or twelve months. The authors noted limitations, including inadequate cell characterization. (9)
This result must be included in an honest discussion of BMC for discogenic pain. It does not establish benefit beyond sham for that protocol. It also does not directly test injections into the tissues surrounding the lumbar spine or SI joint. Intradiscal BMC remains investigational, and pain improvement should not be described as proof that a disc regenerated.
Our published research: treating tissues around the lower back
In 2018, Brent Shaw and I published a four-patient case series examining BMC injections into painful muscle, fascial, and ligament attachment sites around the lower back, including sacroiliac ligaments. These were not intradiscal injections. (10)
At approximately one-year follow-up, all four patients reported less resting and activity-related pain, with mean self-reported overall improvement of 80%. The study illustrates our interest in examining painful supporting tissues even when imaging identifies spinal degeneration.
It was a small uncontrolled case series. It cannot establish that BMC caused the improvement, prove tissue regeneration, or predict another patient’s outcome. It also cannot establish effectiveness for pain confirmed to arise inside the SI joint. Its value is as preliminary clinical observation supporting further research.
Does BMAC work for confirmed SI-joint pain?
Direct clinical evidence for non-expanded autologous BMAC in confirmed SI-joint pain remains limited. Our soft-tissue case series should not be presented as a controlled trial of intra-articular SI-joint treatment.
When discussing a procedure, ask which structure would be injected: the disc, facet joint, SI-joint space, posterior SI ligaments, or another soft-tissue attachment. Evidence and risks for one target cannot automatically be transferred to another.
Neither PRP nor BMAC should be promised to rebuild SI-joint cartilage, reconstruct ligaments, or eliminate the need for surgery. Any discussion should include reasonable alternatives, uncertainty, risks, and the functional goals that matter to the patient.
When back or pelvic pain needs prompt medical evaluation
New loss of bladder or bowel control, numbness in the saddle area, or progressive leg weakness requires urgent assessment. Fever with back pain, significant trauma, suspected fracture, unexplained weight loss, or concern about infection or cancer also warrants prompt medical attention.
Regenerative injections do not correct major mechanical nerve compression, unstable fractures, infection, tumors, or hardware failure. Intradiscal procedures carry particular risks, including potentially serious infection.
Common questions about SI-joint and disc pain
Can I have both a disc problem and SI-joint pain?
Yes. More than one problem may contribute. The task is to identify which findings explain which symptoms and whether treating one source leaves another untreated.
Can SI-joint pain feel like sciatica?
Pain may extend into the leg, creating confusion with sciatica. Numbness, weakness, reflex changes, and the pattern of radiation require careful assessment for nerve involvement.
Can a normal MRI rule out SI-joint pain?
No. A scan may not identify a mechanical SI-joint or surrounding soft-tissue pain source. Imaging remains important when inflammatory disease or another structural cause is suspected.
Does failure of PRP mean I need BMAC?
No. Persistent symptoms are a reason to reassess the diagnosis, target, and alternatives. Failure of one injection does not prove that another biological product will help.
Can these injections help me return to golf?
That depends on the pain source and functional recovery. Our separate article on lower back pain in golfers discusses the demands of the swing and a patient’s experience.
Identify the painful structure before choosing the treatment
The caller’s question brings us back to the most important issue: a disc finding and pain near the SI joint do not tell us, by themselves, what should be treated. A careful history, examination, and appropriately selected tests help connect symptoms to a probable source.
My goal is to understand what is limiting the patient’s life and whether the suspected structure truly explains it. From there, we can discuss conservative care, conventional procedures, or an orthobiologic option with an accurate understanding of what the evidence does—and does not—show.
References
1 DePhillipo NN, Corenman DS, Strauch EL, Zalepa King LA. Sacroiliac Pain: Structural Causes of Pain Referring to the SI Joint Region. Clinical Spine Surgery. 2019;32(6):E282-E288.
2 Brinjikji W, Luetmer PH, Comstock B, et al. Systematic literature review of imaging features of spinal degeneration in asymptomatic populations. AJNR American Journal of Neuroradiology. 2015;36(4):811-816.
3 McCormick ZL, Hurley RW, Anitescu M, et al. Consensus practice guidelines on sacroiliac joint complex pain from a multispecialty, international working group. Regional Anesthesia & Pain Medicine. Published online November 28, 2025. doi:10.1136/rapm-2025-107387.
4 Ellingson AM, Shaw MN, Giambini H, An KN. Comparative role of disc degeneration and ligament failure on functional mechanics of the lumbar spine. Computer Methods in Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering. 2016;19(9):1009-1018.
5 Chen AS, Solberg J, Smith C, et al. Intra-Articular Platelet Rich Plasma vs Corticosteroid Injections for Sacroiliac Joint Pain: A Double-Blinded, Randomized Clinical Trial. Pain Medicine. 2022;23(7):1266-1271.
6 Yadav PJ, Thampi G, Nagakumar JS. Therapeutic Evaluation of Intra-articular Platelet-Rich Plasma, Steroid, and Viscosupplement Injections for Sacroiliitis: A Retrospective Comparative Study. Cureus. 2026;18(3):e105097.
7 Peckham ME, McCormick ZL, Safazadeh G, Hutchins TA, Carlos RC, Shah LM. Comparison of CT-Guided Platelet-Rich Plasma versus Steroid/Anesthetic Injection for Treatment of Sacroiliac Joint Pain: A Randomized, Single-Blinded, Controlled Trial. AJNR American Journal of Neuroradiology. Published online September 24, 2026. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A9307.
8 Wolff M, Shillington JM, Rathbone C, Piasecki SK, Barnes B. Injections of concentrated bone marrow aspirate as treatment for Discogenic pain: a retrospective analysis. BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders. 2020;21:135.
9 Levi D, Tyszko S, Horn S, Pham N, Levin J. Bone marrow concentrate intradiscal injection for chronic discogenic low back pain: A double-blind randomized sham-controlled trial. Interventional Pain Medicine. 2025;4(3):100611.
10 Darrow M, Shaw B. Treatment of Lower Back Pain with Bone Marrow Concentrate. Biomedical Journal of Scientific & Technical Research. 2018;7(2). doi:10.26717/BJSTR.2018.07.001461.
This article is educational and does not provide an individual diagnosis or treatment recommendation. PRP and bone marrow concentrate have not been established as proven regenerative treatments for SI-joint or disc disease. Discuss risks, alternatives, and regulatory status with a qualified physician.