We ask our patients one question all the time: “Why did you decide on shoulder surgery?” The answer is almost always the same: “Because my shoulder MRI looked bad.” A report filled with scary terms like ‘rotator cuff tear’ can feel like a final verdict, pushing you toward a decision you’re not sure about. But here’s the thing: those images don’t tell the whole story. Many people have “bad” scans with little to no pain. This guide is for you. We’ll break down what your MRI really means and explore effective, non-surgical options to get you moving again.

What is a Shoulder MRI and How Does It Work?

If your doctor has recommended a shoulder MRI, you might be wondering what that actually involves. Put simply, an MRI, or Magnetic Resonance Imaging, is a non-invasive way for doctors to see what’s happening inside your body. According to RadiologyInfo.org, an MRI of the shoulder “uses strong magnets, radio waves, and a computer to create detailed pictures of the bones, tendons, muscles, and blood vessels inside your shoulder.” Think of it as creating a detailed map of your joint, allowing your medical team to pinpoint the exact source of your pain or limitation without making a single incision. This technology provides a much clearer and more comprehensive view of the soft tissues, like muscles and ligaments, than a standard X-ray can offer.

Creating Detailed Images Without Radiation

One of the most common questions people have about medical imaging is related to radiation exposure. Here’s some good news: an MRI is not the same as an X-ray or a CT scan. The key difference is that an MRI does not use ionizing radiation to create its images. Instead, it uses a powerful magnetic field and radio waves to generate signals from the body, which a computer then translates into detailed images. This makes it an incredibly safe diagnostic tool, especially for patients who may need multiple scans over time to monitor a condition. You get all the benefits of a highly detailed internal view without the concerns associated with radiation.

Benefits and Risks of a Shoulder MRI

The primary benefit of a shoulder MRI is its ability to provide a clear, detailed look at the complex structures within your shoulder joint, all without surgery. It’s a completely non-invasive test that helps doctors accurately diagnose a wide range of issues. As for the risks, they are minimal for most people. As long as safety protocols are followed, an MRI has almost no risk. The main considerations involve the strong magnetic field. You’ll need to inform your technologist about any metal implants, pacemakers, or other devices in your body. It’s also important to mention if you are pregnant or have kidney problems, especially if a contrast dye might be used during the scan.

Common Reasons for a Shoulder MRI

So, why would your doctor order a shoulder MRI? This powerful imaging tool is typically used when the source of shoulder pain, weakness, or instability isn’t clear from a physical exam or X-rays alone. It helps confirm a suspected diagnosis or investigate symptoms that haven’t improved with initial treatments. Doctors often rely on a shoulder MRI to check for a variety of conditions, including tears in the rotator cuff, injuries to the biceps tendon, and damage to the labrum—the cartilage that lines the shoulder socket. It can also identify issues like arthritis, fractures that are hard to see on an X-ray, infections, or even tumors in the bones and surrounding soft tissues.

Investigating Unexplained Shoulder Pain

If you’re dealing with unexplained shoulder pain, swelling, or a limited range of motion, an MRI can be the key to figuring out the cause. It’s particularly effective for identifying and evaluating sports-related injuries or problems that develop from repetitive movements. Because the shoulder is such a complex joint with many interconnected parts, symptoms can be misleading. An MRI provides the detailed view needed to distinguish between different types of soft tissue injuries, helping your doctor create a targeted and effective treatment plan. This clarity is the first step toward finding relief and getting back to your daily activities without discomfort.

Diagnosing Specific Injuries and Conditions

An MRI excels at diagnosing specific problems within the shoulder’s intricate anatomy. Research published in the National Library of Medicine highlights that MRI can effectively spot tears, inflammation, and damage in the rotator cuff, labrum, and other crucial structures. This level of detail is vital for determining the severity of an injury. For example, it can show whether a rotator cuff tear is partial or complete, which can influence treatment decisions. At the Stem Cell Institute, we often see patients who come to us with MRI results seeking non-surgical options. An accurate diagnosis from an MRI allows us to determine if a patient is a good candidate for regenerative treatments like PRP Therapy or Stem Cell Therapy to help repair damaged tissues.

The MRI Procedure: What to Expect

Knowing what will happen during your MRI can help ease any anxiety you might have. The process is straightforward. You will be asked to change into a gown and remove all metal objects, including jewelry, glasses, and hearing aids. You’ll then lie on a padded table that gently slides into the center of the large, tube-shaped MRI machine. A technologist will be in an adjoining room, but you can communicate with them through an intercom system. The most important part of the procedure is to lie as still as possible to ensure the images are clear. The machine will make loud thumping or knocking noises as it works, but you’ll likely be offered earplugs or headphones to make it more comfortable.

Before, During, and After Your Scan

Before the scan, you can usually eat, drink, and take your medications as normal unless your doctor gives you other instructions. The entire exam is relatively quick, typically lasting between 15 and 45 minutes, depending on the number of images needed. During the scan, you won’t feel anything, but you will hear the machine’s noises. Just focus on relaxing and staying still. After the MRI is complete, you can immediately return to your normal activities. A radiologist will then analyze the images and send a detailed report to your doctor, who will discuss the findings with you at a follow-up appointment and recommend the next steps for your care.

Specialized MRI Techniques

In some cases, a standard MRI might not be enough to see certain subtle injuries with the necessary clarity. To get an even more detailed view, your doctor might order a specialized MRI technique. These advanced methods can highlight specific structures within the shoulder joint, providing crucial information for an accurate diagnosis. Two common specialized approaches are MR arthrography, which involves using a contrast dye, and specific patient positioning techniques. These methods are designed to make it easier for the radiologist to identify smaller tears or abnormalities that might otherwise be missed, ensuring your treatment plan is based on the most precise information possible.

MR Arthrography

For a closer look at the inner workings of the joint, a radiologist may perform an MR arthrogram. This procedure involves injecting a special contrast material, or dye, directly into the shoulder joint before the MRI scan begins. This dye helps to outline the structures inside the joint, such as the cartilage, ligaments, and joint capsule, making them appear brighter and more defined on the final images. According to RadiologyInfo.org, this technique provides “even clearer pictures” and is particularly useful for detecting small tears in the labrum or rotator cuff that might not be visible on a standard MRI.

The Importance of Patient Positioning

How your arm is positioned during the scan can significantly impact the quality and diagnostic value of the images. Different arm positions can stretch or relax certain tendons and ligaments, making tears or other abnormalities more apparent. For example, positioning the arm in a way that externally rotates the shoulder can help highlight issues with the rotator cuff. Experts note that the patient’s position can affect how well problems are seen, so the technologist may ask you to hold your arm in a specific way to get the best possible view of the area in question. This attention to detail ensures your doctor receives the most accurate images to guide your diagnosis.

My Shoulder MRI Looks Bad. Do I Really Need Surgery?

Sometimes someone will have a bad shoulder and a bad MRI and surgery may be the best answer. However, shoulder MRIs may present faulty or inaccurate information. In our many years experience, we have found that when MRI is the sole governing tool relied upon by doctors to recommend treatment, a patient will often be sent to a surgery.

Are Doctors Recommending Too Many Shoulder Surgeries?

This study comes straight from a group of radiologists who submitted their paper to the Journal of the American College of Radiology (1) to bring awareness to the inappropriateness of many MRI orders they see. The bullet points are directly from the research:

  • “MRI is frequently overused.”
  • “We reviewed medical records of 237 consecutive shoulder MRI examinations . . . Of the 237 examinations reviewed:
    • 106 (45%) were deemed to be inappropriately ordered, most commonly because of an absent preceding radiograph. (An MRI was ordered because there was no previous MRI).
    • Nonorthopedic providers had a higher frequency of inappropriate ordering (44%) relative to orthopedic specialists (17%)
    • In the 237 examinations, ultrasound could have been the indicated advanced imaging modality for 157 (66%), and most of these (133/157; 85%) could have had all relevant pathologies characterized when combined with (x-ray).
    • While nonorthopedic provider orders were more likely to be inappropriate, inappropriateness persisted among orthopedic providers.”

Stem cell therapy in the shoulder

 

Does Your Shoulder MRI Tell the Whole Story?

  • In the medical journal Shoulder and Elbow, October 10, 2018: (2) Doctors in the United Kingdom made these observations after  investigating whether magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans can accurately diagnose arthritis of the acromioclavicular joint.
    • “MRI is not helpful in making the diagnosis of acromioclavicular joint arthritis. A focused history and clinical examination should remain the mainstay for surgical decision making.
  • In the medical journal Arthritis care & research, August 2018. Doctors in the United Kingdom looked at common shoulder symptoms and the use of imaging to help with management. They were trying to clear up an unclear situation. Here is what they said: “Shoulder symptoms are common, and imaging is being increasingly used to help with management. However, the relationship between imaging and symptoms remains unclear. This review aims to understand the relationship between imaging-detected pathologies, symptoms, and their persistence.”
    • What was the answer of this research? “There was no significant association between most imaging features and symptoms among high-quality, cross-sectional studies.” (3)
    • What the MRI shows is not always indicative of what the patients pain and range of motion symptoms are, nor can the MRI predict the persistence of these symptoms.

What Your Shoulder MRI Might Not Be Showing You

Here is a well cited study in the medical journal American Journal of Roentgenology. The title: “Shoulder MRI: What Do We Miss?” (4)

This study looked at the things radiologists missed on MRIs that orthopedic surgeons picked up during an arthroscopic procedure. Since the surgeons are using the imaging report as a road map for preoperative assessment and planning, the discovery of missed problems can help further the understanding of the accuracy of the MRI and the MRI interpretation. This research review examined shoulder abnormalities that either are not well seen or are not seen at all on shoulder MRI and therefore are misinterpreted.

In regard to problems of the shoulder cartilage, the study authors noted: “Cartilage lesions are difficult to diagnose. . . and . . .  “Although MRI is an excellent tool for detecting some abnormalities, there are a number of subtler abnormalities of clinical significance that give radiologists greater difficulty.”

In the Journal of the American College of Radiology, researchers looked to “assess the patterns of Appropriate Criteria application among orthopedic specialists and other fields of medicine for use of MRI and radiography and the subsequent necessity for surgical intervention.”

  • Of note: People in the study were patients who already had a “bad” shoulder and this MRI was being ordered to see what was the new source of the patient’s shoulder pain was.
  • A total of 475 patients who underwent shoulder MRI were included in this study.
  • The researchers found significant associations between a patient having had a prior x-ray, being male, and getting subsequently had a shoulder surgery. Orthopedic specialists ordering MRIs had the highest percentage of patients undergo subsequent surgery (33.3%) compared with the second-most, primary care (18.4%), and all other ordering departments.
  • The researchers suggest that if you are a man, had a prior x-ray, had an MRI ordered by an orthopedic surgeon, you were most likely to get a surgery. (5)

 

“Regardless of MR findings, however, physicians should be cautious when recommending surgery in the patient with a vague clinical picture.”

Here is another 2018 study, this time an MRI of the shoulder where SLAP tear is suspected as not really being helpful to many patients with shoulder pain. This one comes from the University of California at Davis.(6)

Here the researchers offer advice on how to make the MRI more successful at really determining what is going on in the shoulder. HOWEVER, even improving the image of the imaging study by variants in the patient’s position during the MRI, may not help the final outcome of the test, should you have a surgery or not. Here is what the researchers said:

“Regardless of MR findings, however, physicians should be cautious when recommending surgery in the patient with a vague clinical picture.”

What if Your MRI Shows a Rotator Cuff Tear?

Here is a study that probably assesses the question about MRI accuracy and what is really happening in the shoulder as good an another. It was published in the Journal of magnetic resonance imaging.(7)

“MRI has become an important diagnostic tool in the evaluation of rotator cuff pathology and the technology continues to evolve. . . . Although MRI findings may be diagnostic in some cases, we find that clinical correlation with history and physical examination is critical to differentiate between anatomic variants, incidental findings, and true pathology. We conclude that good communication between the orthopedic surgeon and the radiologist is necessary to optimize diagnostic yield.”

How Accurate is an MRI for Rotator Cuff Tears?

So, your MRI came back showing a rotator cuff tear. It’s completely understandable to feel concerned, but what does that image actually mean for you? Research from the Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging highlights a crucial point: clinical correlation is essential. The study explains that an MRI might show “anatomic variants” or “incidental findings” that aren’t the real source of your pain. This is why a thorough physical examination and a detailed discussion of your symptoms are just as important as the MRI report. A skilled physician uses the MRI as one piece of the puzzle, not the entire picture, to understand what’s truly going on before recommending a treatment path.

This is why experts caution against rushing into surgery based on imaging alone. One study plainly states that “physicians should be cautious when recommending surgery in the patient with a vague clinical picture,” regardless of the MR findings. The truth is, many people have rotator cuff tears on an MRI without experiencing any pain. Your treatment plan should be based on your unique symptoms and goals. Before committing to an invasive procedure, it’s worth exploring all your options, including regenerative treatments like PRP Therapy, which focuses on healing the tissue without the long recovery of surgery.

What Else Can a Shoulder MRI Find?

The point of this article is to demonstrate how MRIs can send you to a surgery you may not need because of challenges with the MRI accuracy and interpretation. MRI is not a gold standard of care, as demonstrated by countless studies questioning MRIs validity in certain diagnostic cases. In our years of experience we have found that because it is difficult to determine what the true source of shoulder pain generator is, our approach is to regenerate the entire shoulder with our treatments and not focus on a single problem such as a tear on MRI or a tear in the labrum, or a developing bone-on-bone situation. This is demonstrated in the videos above.

 

 

References:

1 Sheehan SE, Coburn JA, Singh H, Vanness DJ, Sittig DF, Moberg DP, Safdar N, Lee KS, Brunner MC. Reducing unnecessary shoulder MRI examinations within a capitated health care system: a potential role for shoulder ultrasound. Journal of the American College of Radiology. 2016 Jul 1;13(7):780-7.
2 Singh B, Gulihar A, Bilagi P, Goyal A, Goyal P, Bawale R, Pillai D. Magnetic resonance imaging scans are not a reliable tool for predicting symptomatic acromioclavicular arthritis. Shoulder & Elbow. 2017 Aug 17:1758573217724080.
3 Tran G, Cowling P, Smith T, Bury J, Lucas A, Barr A, Kingsbury SR, Conaghan PG. What imaging detected pathologies are associated with shoulder symptoms and their persistence? A systematic literature review. Arthritis care & research. 2018 Mar 7.
4 Saqib R, Harris J, Funk L. Comparison of magnetic resonance arthrography with arthroscopy for imaging of shoulder injuries: retrospective study. Annals of The Royal College of Surgeons of England. 2017;99(4):271-274. doi:10.1308/rcsann.2016.0249.
5 Small KM, Rybicki FJ, Miller LR, Daniels SD, Higgins LD. MRI Before Radiography for Patients With New Shoulder Conditions. Journal of the American College of Radiology. 2017 Jun 1;14(6):778-82.
6 Boutin RD, Marder RA. MR Imaging of SLAP Lesions. Open Orthop J. 2018;12:314-323. Published 2018 Jul 31. doi:10.2174/1874325001812010314. 1491

Tears in the Rotator Cuff or Biceps Tendon

One of the most common reasons for a shoulder MRI is to look for a tear in the rotator cuff or the biceps tendon. While an MRI can certainly show these injuries, the image alone might not be giving you the full picture. Research from the Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging highlights that while MRI is an important tool, a physical examination and patient history are critical to tell the difference between a real problem, a normal anatomical variation, or an old finding that isn’t causing your current pain. This means that what an MRI flags as a “tear” might not be the actual source of your discomfort. That’s why a comprehensive evaluation is so important before considering invasive procedures. For many, non-surgical options like PRP Therapy can help the body heal these types of injuries without the need for surgery.

Labrum Damage and Joint Instability

The labrum is a ring of cartilage that helps stabilize your shoulder, and tears in this structure can lead to pain and a feeling of instability. An MRI is often ordered to diagnose labral tears, but its reliability can be questionable. A study published in the journal Shoulder and Elbow found that for certain shoulder conditions, MRI scans are not a reliable predictor of a patient’s symptoms. The researchers concluded that a focused history and a clinical examination should be the main factors in any surgical decision-making. This reinforces the idea that an image of a tear doesn’t automatically mean surgery is the answer. Your symptoms, functional limitations, and a thorough physical assessment are often more telling than the MRI report itself, guiding you toward the most appropriate and effective treatment plan.

Arthritis and Other Joint Diseases

If your doctor suspects arthritis, an MRI can reveal signs like cartilage loss, inflammation, or bone spurs. However, it’s crucial to understand that the severity of these findings on an MRI doesn’t always match the level of pain you’re experiencing. Research from Arthritis Care & Research found no significant link between what imaging shows and a person’s actual symptoms. You could have an MRI that looks quite severe but feel minimal pain, or vice-versa. This disconnect is why we focus on treating the patient, not just their scan results. Regenerative treatments like Stem Cell Therapy aim to address the underlying cause of your pain and improve joint function, offering a path forward that’s based on your personal experience rather than just an image.

Fractures, Infections, or Tumors

While it’s important to be critical of relying solely on MRIs for common shoulder issues, there are situations where this imaging is absolutely essential. According to RadiologyInfo, an MRI is a vital tool when a doctor suspects a more serious condition. This includes looking for subtle fractures that don’t appear on an X-ray, or investigating red flags like a lump in the shoulder, unexplained fever with shoulder pain, or significant difficulty moving the joint. In these cases, an MRI provides the detailed view needed to diagnose potential infections, tumors, or other urgent issues accurately. This allows for prompt and appropriate medical care, highlighting the importance of using this powerful diagnostic tool in the right context.

Frequently Asked Questions

My MRI report says I have a rotator cuff tear. Is surgery my only option? Not at all. An MRI showing a tear can feel like a final diagnosis, but it’s really just one piece of information. Many people walk around with rotator cuff tears and have no pain or limitations. The most important factors are your actual symptoms and how they affect your life. A thorough physical exam is often more telling than the image itself. Before you consider an invasive procedure, it’s worth exploring treatments that focus on healing the tissue and reducing inflammation.

Why do some people have “bad” MRIs but feel little to no pain? This is a great question, and it highlights why we shouldn’t treat the scan instead of the person. An MRI can show “incidental findings,” which are basically signs of past injuries, normal age-related changes, or anatomical variations that aren’t actually causing your current problem. Your body is incredibly adaptive. The presence of a tear on a scan doesn’t automatically equal pain, which is why a treatment plan should be based on your personal experience, not just the radiologist’s report.

How reliable is a shoulder MRI, really? Can it be wrong? While an MRI is a powerful tool, it’s not perfect. Studies have shown that MRI findings don’t always line up with a person’s symptoms. The interpretation of the scan can be subjective, and sometimes the images can miss subtle issues or highlight things that aren’t clinically significant. That’s why experienced physicians use the MRI as a guide, but they rely on a hands-on physical examination and a detailed conversation with you to make a final diagnosis.

If the MRI isn’t the final word, what should I do next to figure out the best treatment? The next step is to get a comprehensive evaluation from a specialist who looks beyond the images. This involves a detailed physical exam where a doctor tests your strength, range of motion, and pinpoints the exact source of your pain. It also means having a real conversation about your symptoms, your activity goals, and how the issue is impacting your daily life. A good treatment plan is built around you, not just your scan results.

What kind of non-surgical treatments can help a shoulder injury shown on an MRI? Regenerative medicine offers powerful options for healing shoulder injuries without the long recovery times of surgery. Treatments like Platelet-Rich Plasma (PRP) Therapy use concentrated healing factors from your own blood to repair damaged tissues, reduce inflammation, and improve function. For more significant issues, Stem Cell Therapy can help regenerate cartilage and other soft tissues. These approaches focus on helping your body heal the entire joint, rather than just surgically addressing one specific finding on an MRI.

Key Takeaways

  • Look Beyond the MRI Report: An image showing a tear or arthritis doesn’t define your condition. A thorough physical exam and your actual symptoms are far more important for determining the right path forward.
  • An MRI Finding Isn’t a Surgical Mandate: Many people have abnormalities on their scans with little to no pain, so a scary-sounding report shouldn’t automatically lead to surgery. Base treatment decisions on your functional limitations, not just the image.
  • Prioritize Treatment for You, Not Your Scan: Before considering an invasive procedure, investigate non-surgical options like PRP or stem cell therapy. These regenerative treatments focus on healing damaged tissue to improve function and relieve pain based on your unique condition.

Related Articles