For years, the standard approach to a torn meniscus involved either removing the damaged part or stitching it back together. While effective for some, these surgical options don’t address the root issue of healing the tissue itself. his article will compare this innovative approach to traditional surgical options, helping you understand the full range of choices for a meniscus repair.
Many people, recommended to a meniscus arthroscopic surgical procedure, are doing research and are exploring meniscus surgery alternatives. This includes the option of regenerative medicine or stem cell injections. Stem Cell Therapy is a treatment for musculoskeletal disorders. It can be used to treat degenerative and acute knee injuries including damage to the meniscus. Stem cells are gathered from a patient’s own bone marrow. Stem cells are “de-differentiated pluripotent” cells, which means that they continue to divide to create more stem cells; these eventually “morph” into the tissue needing repair — for our purposes, collagen and cartilage cells.
Understanding the Meniscus: Anatomy and Function
The meniscus is a shock absorber. It’s a C-shaped wedge of tough, rubbery cartilage that sits between your thigh bone (femur) and shin bone (tibia). Their main job is to cushion the joint, absorb about a third of the force that goes through your knee, and provide stability when you walk, run, or jump. Without a healthy meniscus, the cartilage that covers the ends of your bones would wear down much faster, leading to pain and arthritis.
Why Healing is a Challenge: Blood Supply
One of the biggest challenges with a meniscus tear is its limited ability to heal on its own. The reason for this comes down to blood supply. The outer third of the meniscus has a decent number of blood vessels, which deliver the oxygen and nutrients necessary for repair. However, the inner two-thirds of the meniscus is avascular, meaning it has almost no direct blood supply. Because of this, tears in this inner zone often struggle to heal naturally. This lack of blood flow is a key reason why many meniscus injuries require medical intervention, as the body simply can’t get the resources it needs to the site of the injury to mend the tear.
Types of Meniscus Tears: Traumatic vs. Degenerative
Meniscus tears generally fall into two categories: traumatic and degenerative. A traumatic tear is what most people picture—a sudden injury from a forceful twist or pivot, common in sports like soccer or basketball. This can happen to a perfectly healthy meniscus. On the other hand, a degenerative tear develops gradually over time. As we age, the cartilage can become weaker, more brittle, and more susceptible to tearing from simple, everyday movements like squatting or getting up from a chair. These tears are often the result of cumulative wear and tear rather than a single, specific incident.
Common Non-Surgical Treatments
Before jumping to surgery, most doctors will recommend starting with conservative, non-surgical treatments. This approach often begins with the RICE method: Rest, Ice, Compression, and Elevation. Giving your knee a break from strenuous activity, applying ice to reduce swelling, using a compression bandage for support, and keeping your leg elevated can provide significant initial relief. Over-the-counter anti-inflammatory medications like ibuprofen can also help manage pain and swelling. For many people with small or degenerative tears, these simple, at-home measures are enough to calm symptoms and allow them to return to their normal activities with minimal discomfort.
Physical Therapy and Strengthening
Once the initial pain and swelling have subsided, physical therapy may be recommended. A physical therapist may suggest specific exercises designed to restore your knee’s motion and, most importantly, strengthen the muscles surrounding the joint. Building up your quadriceps, hamstrings, and calf muscles provides better support for the knee, which can reduce the stress on the meniscus and improve overall stability. A strong, stable knee is less likely to buckle or give way, which can prevent further injury and help you manage the symptoms of a tear long-term.
Corticosteroid Injections for Inflammation
If pain and swelling persist despite rest and physical therapy, your doctor might suggest a corticosteroid injection. This procedure involves injecting a powerful anti-inflammatory medication directly into the knee joint. The goal is to quickly reduce inflammation and stiffness, providing temporary relief that can make physical therapy more tolerable and effective. While steroid shots can be helpful for managing symptoms, they don’t heal the tear itself.
When Surgery is on the Table: Types of Meniscus Procedures
When non-surgical treatments don’t provide enough relief, or if the tear is large and causing mechanical symptoms like locking, surgery might be the next step. Most meniscus surgeries are performed arthroscopically, which is a minimally invasive technique. The surgeon makes a few small incisions around your knee and inserts a tiny camera (arthroscope) to see inside the joint, along with small surgical instruments to perform the procedure. This approach results in less pain, minimal scarring, and a faster recovery compared to traditional open surgery. The type of arthroscopic surgery you receive will depend entirely on the nature of your tear, your age, and your activity level.
Arthroscopic Meniscus Repair
The ideal surgical outcome is to save the meniscus, and that’s the goal of an arthroscopic meniscus repair. During this procedure, the surgeon uses tiny sutures or anchors to sew the torn edges of the meniscus back together. This approach is typically reserved for younger patients with traumatic tears located in the outer portion of the meniscus, where there is sufficient blood supply to promote healing. Preserving the entire meniscus is always preferred because it helps maintain the knee’s natural cushioning and stability, reducing the risk of developing arthritis later in life. However, the recovery is longer because the tissue needs time to heal completely.
Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy
Unfortunately, not all tears can be repaired. For complex or degenerative tears located in the inner part of the meniscus with poor blood supply, an arthroscopic partial meniscectomy is the most common procedure. In this surgery, the surgeon carefully trims away and removes only the torn, unstable flap of the meniscus, leaving the healthy, intact portion behind. The goal is to smooth out the damaged area to prevent it from catching or causing pain in the joint. Because nothing is being repaired, the recovery is generally much quicker than a meniscus repair, and patients can often bear weight on their leg shortly after the procedure.
Arthroscopic Total Meniscectomy
In rare cases where the meniscus is damaged beyond repair, a surgeon may perform an arthroscopic total meniscectomy, which involves removing the entire meniscus. This is generally considered a last resort, as removing the knee’s primary shock absorber significantly changes the mechanics of the joint. Without the meniscus to cushion the bones, the articular cartilage is subjected to much higher forces, which dramatically increases the risk of developing osteoarthritis over time. Because of this long-term consequence, surgeons make every effort to preserve as much healthy meniscal tissue as possible and avoid this procedure unless absolutely necessary.
Meniscus Transplant
For younger, active patients (typically under 55) who have previously had a total meniscectomy and are experiencing pain, a meniscus transplant may be an option. This is a more complex and much rarer surgery where a healthy meniscus from a deceased donor (a cadaver) is surgically implanted into the knee. The goal of a transplant is to restore the cushioning function of the meniscus, relieve pain, and potentially slow the progression of arthritis. It’s a highly specialized procedure reserved for a very specific group of patients and is not a common solution for a primary meniscus tear.
Long-Term Outcomes and Success Rates
For the most part, meniscus surgeries are highly effective at relieving the painful symptoms of a tear. Studies show that success rates can be as high as 80% up to five years after the operation, meaning the vast majority of patients experience significant pain relief and improved function. However, the long-term outcome often depends on the type of surgery performed. A meniscus repair that successfully preserves the tissue offers the best long-term prognosis for knee health. A meniscectomy, while effective for pain relief, can accelerate the development of arthritis down the road, which is an important factor to consider.
Stem Cells for a Torn Meniscus: What’s Really Possible?
For many people, the long rehabilitation, possible need for secondary surgery, and other post-surgical factors weigh heavily in their decision making process as to how to proceed to fix their meniscus tear. For many people, regenerative medicine in the form of stem cell therapy may be something that needs to be further explored.
New research into the healing world of the knee meniscus is fascinating. Despite decades of traditional medical beliefs that because of its poor or even absent network of blood vessels and blood supply, parts of the knee meniscus cannot heal. Researchers are discovering the meniscus is in fact, always trying to heal itself.
HOWEVER, the expectation that stem cell therapy can regrow a meniscus from nothing or regenerate extensive amounts of meniscus tissue removed in meniscectomy must be tempered with a realistic expectation of what these treatments can and cannot do.
Stem cell therapy for meniscus tears can help repair deficits in the existing meniscus.
Stem cell therapy when administered as a multi-injection treatment as opposed to a single one-time shot, can also help support, rebuild, and stabilize the knee capsule and help restore a more normal knee function. A more normal knee function can remove stress from the meniscus and other supportive knee tissue such as ligaments and tendons.
What your realistic expectation of what stem cell therapy can do for your meniscus tear must be discussed with a doctor knowledgeable and experienced in the treatment.
Related Articles
